Labeling the Opposition Isn't Winning the Health-Care Reform Debate

My wife and I were talking about this health care debate and how it is attracting society’s fringe protesters, who to me simply hate this President and nothing more. Their side of the debate offers speculation for arguments and little more. Listening to them say the word death-squad is meant to conjure up Nazi death camps. The volume of their rhetoric is intended more to drown out anyone who wants to honestly debate the subject of health-care reform. Shouting out death camps or liar has more to do with fear mongering than to really add any content to the subject. Yelling about death-panels seems to be more of a ploy to scare the elderly than and demonstrates who is really behind this fringe element.

Health care reform advocates pitch program over protests, Des Moines Register

Carpet baggers like South Carolina’s Congressman Joe Wilson shouting out “You lie!” during President Obama’s address to the nation and to congress clearly demonstrates what this is all about. For Wilson it’s about votes back home and solidifying his position with voters. Like most political debate Wilson’s isn’t about truth and consequences but appearances and trying to get votes by appealing to the lowest common denominator in society – fear.

Heckling Of President Rare In US History, AP and KCCI-TV Iowa

Shameful really and it applies to both parties and that is where Barbara and I differ. She blames it on Republicans, of which I’m one. I say it has nothing to do with party labels and to do so, does nothing to advance the discussion.

Party labels aren’t working for us any more. Think back to the Bush Administration lying about the reasons we needed to go into Iraq. There were clearly no weapons of mass destruction; only made-up and exaggerated intelligence data. Where was Wilson then? Why weren’t he and the other Republicans shouting out “Liar!”? And where were the Democrats who voted for the war with Iraq? Why weren’t they shouting out in opposition for more concrete data about the reasons for the war?

How dumb are we, the Parrot Heads?

I’ve written previously about the use of labels and how using labels does nothing to advance the debate. It’s a technique that money grubbers like Ann Coulter, Hannity and Limbaugh have perfected. It’s about raw nerves that turn the brain off, rather than on towards productive thinking.  There are as many Republican voters who are sick and tired of Congressional lies for the sake of special interest campaign contributions and increasing profits as there are Democrats. And there are as many Democratic voters who are in favor of profitable businesses and lower taxes as there are Republicans. Starting out any debate with reference to either Republicans or Democrats is simply a way of polarizing the discussion without regard to content. It derails the discussion and that’s exactly what the special interests hope to do; derail the health care reform discussion to protect special profit interests. Fear is their weapon of choice and it’s the W.M.D. for health-care-reform. It’s a lie and even Republicans who would want health-care reforms can see it is.

The Republican Party does not endear itself to intelligent Republican voters by aligning itself with the fringe in health care reform any more than they did with Palin and her ilk. Their arguments meant to avoid discussing the underlying facts are just as pathetic as arguing, I can see Russia from my kitchen window in Alaska so I must be qualified on all issues of foreign policy.

Get real. Stop dumbing down the discussion with using fear and polarizing labels. It was pathetic then and it is pathetic now. Remember being a voter in a two-party system in which I call myself a Republican doesn’t make me an idiot.  Now that the Cold War has cooled they are pitting us against each other with a new angle. Smarten up America it’s the same game just a different approach. They are still wasting your tax dollars but instead of on implements of war the new war is on health care cost containment. And where is the serious discussion; still wasting away in Margaretville.

And still we don’t have the cheeseburger in paradise. And why?

Thank you Jimmy Buffet and Alan Jackson.

Legitimate Debate or How to Demonize for Dummies? | InjuryBoard ...

... for assuming you know my party affiliation, my leanings in politics, whether I like ... They terrorize the general public with false claims and labels and derail ... 101k

Living on the edge of reason; Promoting Hatred as a Cultural Norm ...

... 6. Talk over people you disagree with. (See rule 1.). 7. Memorize labels for groups you hate and use them often. (Liberals vs. Conservatives.). ... 101k

What if looting your retirement accounts weren’t a crime? ...

... This isn’t rocket science – its politics, power and money ... The problem essentially comes down to confusion caused by similar labels being used for adult and ... 101k

Federal Preemption Part II: What issues raise questions of federal ...

... See the Federalism Project, Federal Preemption: Law, Economics, Politics. ... overdosed with Heparin due to what the hospital staff claimed were labels that caused ... 101k

America the melting pot is having a meltdown. | InjuryBoard Des ...

... to a false conclusion. Probably the most obvious are the labels “liberal” and “conservative”. The entire liberal/conservative ... 101k