Chicago Tribune, Suit blames hotel for death from Legionnaires’ disease.
Suit has been filed in Chicago by the law firm of Capron & Avgerinos naming as a defendant the Marriott International. The plaintiff is the widow of Thomas Joseph Keane, 66 who after dining at the JW Marriott hotel at 151 W. Adams Street in Chicago contracted Legionnaires’ disease and died. The JW Marriott was owned and operated by Prime Group, Inc., also believed to have been named in the suit, although the pleadings are not yet available to me. A contaminated fountain is the suspected source. From the commercial real estate angle, this will be interesting litigation. HVAC, maintenance and design will all be subjects to explore during discovery. A background in commercial real estate should help the lawyers.
Test results also showed that the hotel’s pool, the spa's whirlpool and both the men's and women's locker rooms contained “the same species of Legionella,” according to the Chicago Department of Public Health.
So what is Legionnaires’ disease? - It’s an infection more formally described as “Legionellosis”.
[Some of you may recognize Dan Capron as a football referee in the Big Ten. Dan Capron will referee at the Independence Bowl between Missouri and North Carolina on December 26, 2011 in Shreveport, LA.]
New York State Department of Health
Legionellosis (Legionnaires' disease)
Last Reviewed: November 2006
What is legionellosis?
Legionellosis is a bacterial disease which may cause pneumonia. Fewer than 100 cases are reported each year in upstate New York. Most cases occur as single isolated events. Outbreaks are relatively rare.
Why is it called legionellosis?
An outbreak of this disease in Philadelphia in 1976, largely among people attending a state convention of the American Legion, led to the name "Legionnaires' Disease." Subsequently, the bacterium causing the illness was named Legionella pneumophila and the name of the illness was changed to legionellosis.
Is this a new disease?
No. The bacterium was first identified in 1976, but earlier cases have been confirmed as far back as 1947.
How widespread is legionellosis?
It is estimated that about 25,000 people develop legionellosis in the United States each year. An additional unknown number are infected with the Legionella bacterium and have mild symptoms or no illness at all. Cases occur sporadically and in outbreaks. Outbreaks occur most often in the summer but cases occur all year round.
How severe is the illness?
Legionellosis can be a mild respiratory illness or it can be severe enough to cause death. From 10 to 40 percent of healthy adults have antibodies showing previous exposure to the organism, but only a small percentage have a history of previous pneumonia.
Where are Legionella found?
Legionella exist naturally in water and moist soil. They have been found in creeks and ponds, hot and cold water taps, hot water tanks, water in air conditioning cooling towers and evaporative condensers, and soil at excavation sites.
How is legionellosis spread?
The disease appears to be spread through the air from a soil or water source. All studies to date have shown that person-to-person spread does not occur.
Who gets legionellosis?
People of any age can get legionellosis but the disease most often affects the elderly. People with underlying illnesses such as cancer or those with lowered immune system resistance to disease are also at higher risk. It rarely occurs in otherwise healthy people.
What are the usual symptoms of legionellosis?
The early symptoms of legionellosis may be flu-like with muscle aches, headache, tiredness and dry cough followed by high fever, chills and occasionally diarrhea. Temperatures commonly reach 102-105 degrees Fahrenheit and chest X-rays often show pneumonia.
How soon do symptoms occur/appear?
The incubation period for legionellosis ranges from two to 10 days, but is usually five to six days.
What is the treatment for legionellosis?
Antibiotics such as erythromycin, levaquin or azithromycin appear to be effective in treating the disease.
Why is legionellosis so difficult to diagnose?
Legionellosis often causes symptoms similar to those caused by other organisms, including influenza virus and other types of bacterial pneumonia. In addition, the specific laboratory tests needed to confirm the diagnosis are not always requested. The diagnosis depends on very specialized laboratory tests involving culture of the patient's sputum or detecting the organism in urine. Routine laboratory tests will not identify the Legionella bacteria.
When does the health department investigate a case of legionellosis?
Because sporadic cases are common and presently not preventable, they are often investigated only to confirm the diagnosis and rule out an outbreak. If an outbreak occurs, an investigation to look for a possible environmental source is conducted.
Revised: June 2004
- CDC, Legionellosis Resource Site (Legionnaires' Disease and Pontiac Fever)
- Patient Facts: Learn More about Legionnaires’ disease, CDC
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Travelers' Health - CDC - Centers for Disease
- CDC - Data & Statistics - Centers for Disease
- Vaccines and Immunizations - Centers for Disease